As the Build-to-Rent (BTR) sector gathers momentum in Australia, global markets like New York offer invaluable insight. This week, our General Manager is on the ground in New York, a city facing an acute housing shortage and responding with innovative, large-scale rental solutions that Sydney can learn from.

New York's Tight Rental Market: A Catalyst for BTR Growth

New York City continues to face a severe rental housing crunch. Vacancy rates are sitting below 1.5%, while median rents in Manhattan have soared past USD 4,650 (AUS$6842). Demand is strong and supply remains constrained, factors that have helped fuel a significant uptick in purpose-built rental developments across the city.

In just a few years, New York’s Build-to-Rent stock has grown by more than 60%, supported by institutional investors and forward-thinking public policy. It’s a response born of necessity, but one that has created a highly sophisticated, professionally managed rental market.

Office-to-Residential Conversions: Unlocking Supply

One of the boldest strategies employed in New York is the adaptive reuse of obsolete office buildings into residential communities. In 2025 alone, more than 8,000 rental units are expected to be delivered through office-to-residential conversions.

Projects like 25 Water Street, set to become the largest such conversion in U.S. history, demonstrate how the city is unlocking value from underutilised assets. These conversions are especially relevant for Sydney, where shifts in CBD office demand could create similar opportunities in areas like North Sydney, Parramatta, and the inner west.

Case Study: Stuyvesant Town–Peter Cooper Village — A BTR Icon in Manhattan

Perhaps the most iconic example of BTR in New York is Stuyvesant Town–Peter Cooper Village, a purpose-built rental community that has stood the test of time.

Overview

Location: East Manhattan, between 14th and 23rd Streets

Size: Over 11,000 rental apartments across 80 acres

Owner: Blackstone Group (acquired for ~$5.3 billion in 2015)

Legacy: Built in the 1940s as post-war housing, now a benchmark for professionally managed urban BTR

What Makes It Stand Out

- A true long-term rental community, with a mix of market-rate and rent-stabilised units

- Managed by a dedicated on-site team, delivering consistent service and maintenance

- Green spaces, community amenities, and resident engagement at the core of its design

- Financially sustainable due to institutional ownership and economies of scale

Lessons for Sydney

‍StuyTown proves the viability of large-scale, long-term rental housing in dense urban areas. It shows the importance of:

- Building for enduring rental tenure

- Prioritising community experience and liveability

- Embedding scale, management, and long-term operational planning from day one

As Sydney develops its own BTR identity, StuyTown’s model is a strong reminder that Build-to-Rent is more than just housing—it’s about shaping rental communities that last generations.

Investment Trends: Focus Shifts to Free-Market Multifamily

In parallel with development trends, investor sentiment in New York has shifted toward free-market multifamily assets, driven by long-term rental demand and flexibility. In 2024 alone, New York’s multifamily sector recorded USD 8.9 billion in sales, with private capital playing an increasingly dominant role.

While rent-stabilised assets continue to face regulatory headwinds, purpose-built, professionally managed rental buildings have remained highly attractive to investors seeking predictable yields and operational control.

Bringing It Back to Sydney

As our GM explores these leading examples firsthand, the relevance to Sydney is clear. Our city shares many of New York’s structural challenges—housing undersupply, affordability pressures, and growing demand for secure, quality rental living.

The key takeaways for Sydney’s BTR evolution:

- Tap into underused spaces, like ageing commercial stock, for rapid housing delivery

- Build and operate with longevity, scale, and service in mind

- Foster vibrant, resident-focused communities, not just apartments

By learning from global pioneers like New York, we’re sharpening our vision to help shape Sydney’s next generation of rental living—one built on stability, quality, and long-term value for both residents and investors.

‍